The Tax Commissioner’s hit list

Every so often the Australian Taxation Office (ATO) sends a ‘shot across the bow’ warning taxpayers where their gaze is focussed. Last month in a speech to the National Press Club, Tax Commissioner, Chris Jordan did exactly that.


He said that part of the reason for this public outing was to highlight that the gap between the amount of tax the ATO collects and the amount they think should be collected has risen to well over 6 per cent according to the Commissioner.

“The risks of non-compliance highlighted by our gap research so far in this market are mainly around deductions, particularly work-related expenses,” the Commissioner stated. “The results of our random audits and risk-based audits are showing many errors and over-claiming for work related expenses – from legitimate mistakes and carelessness through to recklessness and fraud.

“In 2014-15, more than $22 billion was claimed for work-related expenses. While each of the individual amounts over-claimed is relatively small, the sum and overall revenue impact for the population involved could be significant.”

This Is what was then revealed as areas where they will look to rein in unwarranted claims.

Individuals – the hit list

  • Claims for work-related expenses that are unusually high relative to others across comparable industries and occupations;
  • Excessive rental property expenses;
  • Non-commercial rental income received for holiday homes;
  • Interest deductions claimed for the private proportion of loans; and
  • People who have registered for GST but are not actively carrying on a business.

While small in value, the ATO are also concerned about the amount of people who appear to be claiming deductions by default for items such as clothing expenses. In 2014–15, around 6.3 million people made a claim for $150 for work related clothing - the level you can claim without having to fully substantiate your expenses. Those 6.3 million claims amounted to $1.8 billion in deductions.

Small business – the hit list

  • Those deliberately hiding income or avoiding their obligations by failing to register, keep records and/or lodge accurately;
  • Businesses that report outside of the small business benchmarks for their industry;
  • Employers not deducting and/or not sending PAYG withholding amounts from employee wages;
  • Employers not meeting their superannuation guarantee obligations;
  • Businesses registered for GST but not actively carrying on a business;
  • Failure to lodge activity statements; and
  • Incorrect and under reporting of sales.

If your business is outside of the ATO’s benchmarks, it’s important to be prepared to defend why this is the case. This does not mean that your business is doing anything wrong, but it increases the possibility that the ATO will look more closely at your business and seek an explanation.

Private groups – the hit list

  • Tax or economic performance not comparable to similar businesses;
  • A lack of transparency in tax affairs;
  • Large, one-off or unusual transactions, including transfer or shifting of wealth;
  • A history of aggressive tax planning;
  • Choosing not to comply or regularly taking controversial interpretations of the law;
  • Lifestyle not supported by after-tax income;
  • Treating private assets as business assets; and
  • Poor governance and risk-management systems.

Property developers – the hit list

  • Developers using their SMSF to undertake or fund the development and subdivision of properties leading to sale;
  • Where there has been sale or disposal of property shortly after the completion of a subdivision and the amount is returned as a capital gain;
  • Where there is a history in the wider economic group of property development or renovation sales, yet a current sale is returned as a capital gain;
  • How profit is recognised where related entities undertake a development (i.e., on the development fees as well as sales of the completed development);
  • Whether inflated deductions are being claimed for property developments;
  • Multi-purpose developments - where units are retained for rent in a multi-unit apartment, to ensure that the costs are appropriately applied to the properties produced.

These are just a small sample of the ATO’s area of focus.Other areas include tax and travel related expenses and self-education expenses. We’ll guide you through the risk areas pertinent to your individual situation but if you are concerned about any of the ‘hit list’ areas mentioned, please contact us.

Disclaimer - This article provides general information only, current at the time of production. Any advice in it has been prepared without considering your personal circumstances. You should seek professional advice before acting advice offered here. 

The article was written by Sandeep Singh, CEO of the business advisory firm, The Golden Chest. He is an accredited value improvement business advisor, chartered tax and management accountant with over eight years’ experience advising business and professionals on tax planning matters.

If you would like a more detailed look at tax planning, you can download a newsletter on the subject from The Golden Chest via the following link: